Finding the best boat buffer will be an oversimplified quest for most of you. Experience has shown that most people think that polishing car paint is essentially the same as polishing a boat.
While the fact does remain that many of the same tools and products do indeed work across the spectrum of car and boat polishing, understanding the differences between gel coat and the different buffers will go far to avoid disappointment and achieving optimum results. Follow along with this comprehensive review and see if you don't walk away more informed than you ever thought possible!
Q.-I heard that car paint and gel coat is really the same when it comes to polishing and waxing.
A.-The fact is that while you could virtually use the same of everything to polish a boat as you do to polish your car, the real difference will be more about results.
(Many people will co-mingle fiberglass and gel coat when referring to their boat. While fiberglass is used to make boat hulls and decks, fiberglass actually refers to the fiberglass cloth used in the gel coat process. Gel coat is the top layer that is exposed and the material we are officially referring to and working with. I will also use the terms buffer and polisher interchangeably as there is no official difference, and no standard rule in the industry as to which is which. Polishers and buffers mean the same thing in the detailing world regardless of working on cars or boats.)
Gel coat is very porous and very durable. Gel coat has no protective layer to it like the clear coat on car paint and therefore oxidizes easily. You may not have noticed but the majority of boats are white. One of the reasons is that white gel coat does not reveal the oxidation like darker colors of gel coat would.
Just know that while choosing a professional grade boat buffer is critical, it is also critical that you understand that polishing on gel coat is very different than polishing on car paint. And the real difference is the amount of work it requires when polishing on gel coat to get the results you are after. This is all due to gel coat being such a strong and durable material.
Q.- What is the critical point I need in understanding the difference between car paint and gel coat?
A.- If you have a boat that is in pristine condition, it will mater not what kind of boat polisher or product you use to polish your boat since your boat is in excellent condition and no level of oxidation exists. But most people go looking for the best boat buffer and polish due to some level of oxidation, and this is the point where selecting the right boat polisher and polish will make or break your world. Unless you have aggressive enough tools and products, your boat oxidation removal will be minimal at best. To truly perform oxidation removal and gel coat restoration, traditional random orbital or DA car polishers will be the equivalent of bringing a BB gun to a gun fight!
Traditional dual-action (DA) or random orbital car polishers just aren't capable of producing the kind of friction required to produce the results you will want on your boat.
Q.- So what kind of boat buffer do I need to do the job?
A. - A high-speed buffer; also referred to as a rotary buffer. These buffers are buried in bad press mostly due to inexperienced and/or misinformed guys repeating bad information. The fact remains that gel coat requires the friction and heat that can only be produced through these high-speed polishers. Dual-action (DA) or random orbital polishers simply cannot produce the necessary heat and friction required to remove oxidation from gel coat...unless of course you are willing to spend an eternity using the wrong tool to achieve desired results.
Q.- I heard that high-speed buffers should never be used as they leave swirl marks and can damage paint?
A.- We must remember a few things here; first, we are talking gel coat. And second, gel coat is not car paint. The good news is that gel coat is very tough and can withstand far more pressure, heat, and friction than car paint. This means good news to any beginner looking to polish their own boat, but at the same time this is exactly why a high-speed polisher is needed to achieve any discernible or lasting results. I have seen many do-it-yourselfers try and save a buck by spending the entire weekend with their fathers old-school orbital polisher, or the dual-action (DA) car polishers that have become so popular these days, only to have the oxidation re-appear a few weeks later due to their inexperience and ignorance of what they are doing, and what they are working on.
You may take satisfaction in polishing on your boat with a very "safe" dual-action car polisher, and feel a sense of accomplishment until you catch the area you just polished in the right lighting only to realize that that very safe dual-action polisher hasn't really removed the oxidation from your boat.
Q.- Now that I know a rotary or high-speed polisher is the best boat buffer, what are the best high-speed buffers I should consider for polishing my boat?
A.- Glad you asked as there are (3) choices that any experienced professional would recommend.The biggest difference between all of the boat buffers below is about cost. They are all quality tools and will perform, but the difference is cost. I lay out the more subtle differences below.
Darren's Tips: You could spend days researching the endless reviews about the best boat polishers, compounds, and polishing pads only to find yourself more confused, frustrated, and still no closer to getting what you really want....
a shiny, glossy, and protected boat!
So I am limiting my professional recommendations to a minimum for some very specific reasons:
Darren's Tip: I start with this compound since I have learned that the right compound is just as important as choosing the right boat buffer. Choosing the right polishing pads is also critical to the equation. I am not including any of the dual-action (DA) car polishers on this page since I am of the opinion that a rotary buffer is the best choice for boat polishing due to the nature of gel coat/fiberglass.
Also if you decide against picking one of the top rated boat polishers from this page, you now know my first choice in the best compound to use when polishing your boat. Despite this being aggressive enough to use for heavy duty oxidation removal, it finishes down to an excellent shine. Just ease up on the pressure and speed with your final passes of your buffer after your initial cutting is done.
CSI Rip Cut Compound Quart 62-M200-Q
CSI Marine Wax Quart 62-M204-Q
Something you need to realize is just how easily gel coat/fiberglass will oxidize. For this reason, consistent application of a quality marine grade wax will be necessary.
After you have taken the time to pick the best boat buffer and compound your boat to remove all the oxidation, you will need consistent applications of a quality marine wax.
Makita 9237CX3 Makita 7" Polisher, 10 AMP, 600-3,000 RPM, var. spd., loop handle with foam pad and bag, ,
DEWALT DWP849X 7-Inch/9-Inch Variable Speed Polisher with Soft Start
FLEX (PE 14-2 150) POLISHFLEX Compact Variable Speed Rotary Car Polisher
I assume that anyone looking for the best boat buffer is dealing with some level of fiberglass oxidation or gel coat oxidation. I also know that most people grossly underestimate the nature of gel coat when it comes to polishing. It is one thing to polish your boat and have it look nice, entirely different to actually perform oxidation removal. Most people who attempt to polish their boat will do so with materials and tools far too mild for lasting results. Boats really can handle and do require far more pressure, heat, and friction than that of cars.
Darren's Tips: If you are a beginner, you need to accept there will always be a learning curve. There will also be a learning curve to any new product you switch to using as every product will reveal it's own unique characteristics.
Just remember that working on gel coat will require far more product, pressure and even more speed if you are familiar with polishing car paint. Gel coat is a very tough material and can handle much in the way of aggressiveness when compared to buffing car paint.
Darren's Tip: While it is not a true requirement, since I started using this universal pad washer I have grown to love the benefits it offers and question how I managed before these came along.
While they are what I consider an expensive add-on, I also consider it a worthy expense for the basic reason:
"Whether you are polishing a boat or car; it is hard work! Having the best tools, products, and accessories will make the job dramatically easier and better. The right tools and products will literally make the difference between success and failure as well as overall user experience. Do not take this lightly!"
Grit Guard Universal Pad Washer
Most boats or white and there is a reason for that. Since gel coat oxidizes so quickly, the majority of boats are white, or have mostly white gel coat since the white gel coat hides oxidation much better than any colored gel coat.
Regardless of whether your boat is all white or has some color to it, the polishing is the same and the Rip Cut Compound will work. You just need to accept that working on any colored gel coat will always be more difficult than buffing on a white boat.
Many boat polishing kits will contain either foam pads only or a combination of wool and foam pads, you may shy away from what might seem like a scary proposition of using an aggressive wool pad; especially if this will be your first time buffing a boat. Just know that if you want to achieve any permanent results you will be required to use a wool pad.
While the combination of a rotary polisher, wool pad, and a rubbing compound will seem particularly intimidating to any beginner, just know that it is not as scary as it might appear. This is why I love these new boat buffers above that have not only the soft-start trigger, but can be dialed down to a very low 600 RPM operating speed. In the event you have never used a polisher before; 600 RPM's is incredibly low and you will be pleasantly surprised as to how easy it is in using a buffer for the first time.
And the recommended Rip Cut Compound, the wool pads, along with any of the boat polishers above will allow you to safely learn how to not only polish in general, but polish your boat specifically.
AES Industries Buffing Pad Cleaning Tool
If you have learned something of value from this page, pay it forward by sharing to your favorite forum or social group.
Speaking from experience; boat polishing or fiberglass restoration is not an easy task even for a trained professional. But with my recommendations above you will at least have a fighting chance to getting professional results, and not be lead down the wrong path only to add further frustration to an already frustrating proposition!